*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://p15.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/wohaver
Review Requests: ON
360 Public Reviews Given
373 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
I like to emphasize the positive attributes of your work, but I will offer suggestions for improvement if I'm able.
I'm good at...
Recognizing poetic devices and fiuguratve expression.
Favorite Genres
I'm open to all genres but am particulary fond of social or cultural complaints.
Favorite Item Types
I prefer structured forms of poetry to free verse but review either.
I will not review...
I only review single poetic works - not collections.
Public Reviews
Previous ... -1- 2 3 4 5 ... Next
1
1
Review of NAOMI  
Review by Liam
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
I absolutely enjoy the unity of sound in this presentation of your name…

… and so I tip my hat
2
2
Review of Depreciation  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Don Two ,

I just finished reading your poem, "Depreciation for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION: *Thought*
This is one of those examples where the poetry kind of sneaks up on you. It’s really quite deceptive. While the content is really quite light and somewhat humorous (as supported by the dancing rhythm and couplet rhyming) the theme actually is suggestive of a problematic characteristic central to a capitalistic society which is particularly noticeable in large consumer items. How is it that depreciation is so immediate on major purchases.

I really identified with this poem on a personal level because of a similar experience with the first new car that I purchased. I had only owned it for two weeks when another driver rear ended me and totaled my vehicle. I was surprised when his insurance company offered to settle with me for several thousand dollars less than what I owed on the new purchase – as this was its current “blue-book” value. I was somewhat obstinate, simply because I couldn’t afford not to be, and refused the offer. Still, I find this type of curved-equity quite alarming.

The poem is formatted is six quatrains of iambic tetrameter of (a-a-b-b) rhyme and flows very smoothly. It also contains some very good imagery (both visual and olfactory) that effectively increases the comical nature of the experience and adds to the reader’s enjoyment.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS: *Notepady*
I have no suggestions for improvement.

*Bookstack* WHAT I LIKED BEST: *Delight*
The first thing I should mention is the originality of the theme. I don’t remember ever reading anything similar. Also, how funny (although I’m certain – not at the time) is it to watch your new car swallowed up by the voracious earth. My favorite lines are “I only had it for a spell, that new car smell resided well.”

*Starr* Rating: *stargray**Starbr**Starb**Starg**Halfstar*
I really enjoyed this read, as well as several others I have discovered in your port. I am looking forward to reading more of your poetry.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Use when reviewing poems for PDG
3
3
Review of Reaching upwards  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hi Whiskerfacebythefireplace ,

I just finished reading your poem, "Reaching upwards for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION: *Thought*
This is a beautiful poem that illustrates the emergence of low points in a relationship and the value of not allowing them to dominate the spirit. The poet’s choice to use the imagery of seasonal changes is well fitted to the purpose. I really enjoyed how - the bitterness of winter hold the promises of spring parallels the lows and highs of a relationship – is captured in stanzas one and two.

Stanzas three through five shift to focus on the merits of acceptance, and recognition that personal growth often springs forth in the heritage of adversity, if we simply take a moment to step back objectively to experience the fullness of life contained therein, and that this realization enables us to reach even greater heights as our reward.

The purpose of the poem is well conceived and executed effectively in five sextets of rhyming couplets of predominately iambic tetrameter. The flow is generally pretty good, with only a few brief struggles.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS: *Notepady*
I normally don’t focus on the impact of capitalizing the beginning word of each line, as I consider that merely a poet’s choice of formatting. But in the case of this poem, which uses a lot of excellent enjambment and some very complex structure of thought, I believe the read would be greatly enhanced to alter this and use capitalization to mark the beginning of each new thought rather than every line.

Also, as I mentioned above, there are some brief hiccups in the flow of the read. As you continue to reread and edit your work, I would suggest considering the use of a thesaurus to refine these areas. As an example (because I don’t choose to influence your word choice), the line (S1-L6) “That wrapped him when we first kissed.”, flows very differently as “surrounding him when we first kissed.” Of course, these types of edits fall clearly within poetic prerogative.

*Bookstack* WHAT I LIKED BEST: *Delight*
I always appreciate a powerful opening and the lines “Fretting about a winter storm Does nothing to keep me warm.” Is an excellent hook and really drew me into the poem. I was also enraptured by “I smile and gently touch down Wearing gladness as my crown.”

*Starr* Rating: *Starbr* *Starb**Starg**Staro**Halfstar*
This is a very satisfying read full of promise, thank you for sharing it.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Use when reviewing poems for PDG
4
4
Review by Liam
In affiliation with Muse Masters Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
A Muse Masters Micro Review
The opinions contained in this review are only those of one person. Take what you can use, but don't be shy about discarding what you cannot.

Greetings LostGhost: Seeking & Learning }

Musings on:
BOOK
Quilting the Poems  (18+)
A journal to keep track of my poetic thoughts.
#1943513 by LostGhost: Seeking & Learning


*Angel*You totally blew me away with your opening line, "Tether your hopes to the pole of perseverance." Now that is poetry, if I have ever heard it, and it sets the tone very well for all the content that follows.

One of the things that I really admired is the courage of this poem. It doesn't make any pretense or promises about what tomorrow may bring. Some days you will get the bear - and - some days the bear will get you. The only promise is that tomorrow will bring something new to your life's experience. And the overall implication is that there is equal value on both the good and the bad days.

So - "Tether your hopes to the pole of perseverance". I am a much better person for having read this poem, so thank you for sharing your work.


Regards,
Liam

Micro Review Signature

5
5
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
My new PDG review signature


Hi DRSmith ,

I just finished reading your poem, "THE BANE OF CHIEF TWO-TENTS for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION: *Thought*
While this poem's content is based on an old joke, I really enjoyed reading very much for two reasons. First, I am a really big fan of the limerick form and this poem chains together three excellent stanzas that utilize the rhythm and rhyme of this form very well (although surprisingly they are not formatted traditionally).

The second reason that I enjoyed it so much is that I also appreciate the humour in the word play "two tents" (too tense). Even though it is not original - it is still quote comical and I liked it very much.

I also thought it was an interesting choice that the poet decided to format this poet much like you would expect to see as a sonnet.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS: *Notepady*
I don't have any suggestions for improvement.

*Bookstack* WHAT I LIKED BEST: *Delight*
My favorite lines have to be those found in stanza one. This is because when you combine feminine end line rhymes with the bouncy rhythm of the anapestic feet so prevalent in limericks it seems to double the impact on the ear. At least, that's how it sounds to me.

Also, I have to include the rhyming couplet at the end because, after all, that is the climax of the humour as it includes the pun "two tents:.

*Starr* Rating: *stargray**Starbr**Staro**Starr**Halfstar*
This was a lot of fun to read. The meter is flawless and the word selection is very good as well.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Use when reviewing poems for PDG
6
6
Review of Wonderland  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
My new PDG review signature


Hi Jaeff | KBtW of the Free Folk ,

I just finished reading your poem, "Wonderland for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION: *Thought*
This poem is really remarkable. I love the idea of using the Alice in Wnderland story as the theme. It is a well known story with which nearly everybody can identify - this helps to promote the content to a higher level. GREAT JOB on this choice.

The form you selected (Kyrielle Sonnet) is a perfect choice for the content, and your rhythm and flow are equally superb. I know that the form allows for either rhyming couplets (a,a,b,B) or alternate rhyme {a,b,a,B) and I think your choice of rhyming couplets is ideal when paired when coupled with iambic tetrameter. I also love how you inverted the first foot in line one - stanza one. This literally pushes the reader "down the rabbit hole." SPECTACULAR!

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS: *Notepady*
It is beyond my capability to offer any suggestions for improvement. This poem is absolutely perfect.

*Bookstack* WHAT I LIKED BEST: *Delight*
Reading this poem aloud is truly a special treat. You use of sound is nothing short of awesome. I particularly like how you use alliteration in both of your refrain lines (Welcome to wondrous Wonderland. Come deeper down the rabbit hole)

*Starr* Rating: *stargray**Starbr* *Starb**Starg**Staro**Starr**Halfstar* This poem deserves every star I can find to include. I have added this poem to my list of favorites so I can revisit it from time to time. It is so much fun to read aloud.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Use when reviewing poems for PDG
7
7
Review of Celtic Memories  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (5.0)
My new PDG review signature


Hi 🌕 HuntersMoon ,

I just finished reading your poem, "Celtic Memories for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION: *Thought*
I have had more fun reading this poem than I've had for several months. First of all, the English Sonnet is by far my favorite poetry form and this one is constructed masterfully. The iambic pentameter is quite conversational and flows naturally and uninterrupted and the end line rhymes are perfect and unforced.

Added to this enticement, I find the content very creative and enjoyable to read. I have often considered that the Irish must be the most prolific race to ever exist because it seems that so many people claim some level inherited within their lineage - particularly around St. Patrick's Day. The connection between some of the great Irish authors and poets, to the perpetual transmission of legend and lore, is absolutely inspirational and enables the content to gel seamlessly and creates opportunity for a volta that ties the mystical to the natural.

The poem touched me multi-dimensionally. It effectively transported me to the days of my youth when these poems and stories were "whispered in my ear", and at the same time instilled a bit of nostalgia for that "emerald land" where the old world magic is still alive and thriving.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS: *Notepady*
This poem needs no alteration but I did notice what I presume to be a typo in line one. "The voice of Joyce float...", for noun/verb agreement should be "The voice of Joyce floats..."

*Bookstack* WHAT I LIKED BEST: *Delight*
Every line in this poem is so powerful that selecting my favorites would require me to simply copy the poem in its entirety, That said, I did especially enjoy the internal rhyme of "The voice of Joyce...". Each of the authors and poets highlighted are personal favorites. And, the closing couplet establishes the perpetual nature of the magic of the old world.

*Starr* Rating: *stargray**Starbr* *Starb**Starg**Staro**Starr**Halfstar*
This poem is a cut above the superb. I'm sure to reread it often.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Use when reviewing poems for PDG
8
8
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hi 🌷 Carol St.Ann 🌷 ,

I just finished reading your poem, "Curse of the Setting Moon for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION: *Thought*

This is a well written and entertaining poem that, I found is packed full of surprises. It compares and contrasts the emotional perspectives of a female werewolf (shewolf). For me this was a very intriguing concept because for some reason I have always identified werewolves with the male gender. Also, I found the theme very unique because my initial presumption is that the transformation into the wolf would be the unwelcomed event, but as the title and descriptive line suggests, that is not the case here. Rather, it is the transformation from the wolf that is unwelcomed. I really loved being surprised by the contradictory perspective. The imagery created supports this theme very well.

The poem is formatted in eleven quatrains of logaoedic verse that, with the exception of one line (“Cues emancipated time.”), is eight syllables per line. Initially it is difficult to read well because while the majority of the stanzas are four lines of tetrameter (4-4-4-4), stanzas one, four, and seven read more naturally as alternating tetrameter and trimester (4-3-4-3), and stanza eight is kind of a hybrid mix of (4-3-4-4). But with practice the poem can be read smoothly.

The word selection in the poem is excellent, promoting vivid imagery while at the same creating a quality of sound that is both exciting and adventurous. I really enjoyed the numerous examples of internal rhyme (of the many my two favorites are [replaces – longcase’s] and [pique – physique]). Another highlighted feature is feminine ending of lines used stanza two {lines 1 and 3) and stanza seven (lines 2 and 4).

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS: *Notepady*

The only meaningful suggestion I have relates to the line “As once more, hid’ous form I take.”. This contraction really caused me to stumble. While I assume you used it for fidelity of the “eight syllable” count – my preference would be “As once more, hideous form I take.”. It is okay to “break the rules” – give yourself permission to do that.

*Tools* POETIC DEVICES: *Key*

In addition to some of the elements captured in the overview section above, there is very good use of consonance and assonance throughout the poem, also great examples of connotation and symbolism

*Bookstack* WHAT I LIKED BEST: *Delight*
While there are many lines that I could single out as favorites because of their virtues, what I really liked the best is how you interconnected the opening and closing stanzas using the “hooting owl” and the concepts of time and freedom. This is very nicely accomplished. Oh, and I also enjoyed the image that you added.

*Starr* Rating: *stargray**Starbr* *Starb**Starg**Halfstar*
This is a very good read.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Use when reviewing poems for PDG
9
9
Review of Whobody  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello Brenpoet ,

I visited your port today, and found so much poetry I loved that selecting one to review is a challenge. I finally decided on this poem, "Whobody and I'm reviewing it for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION: *Thought*
I enjoy so much about this poem that it is difficult to know where to begin to highlight its attributes - so you may find me rambling a bit on the analysis. This poem is about how a young lad's imaginary friend creates mischievous events in his daily activities. I readily identify with this = as I recall parallel circumstances in my own youth. This similarity kept me enthralled and chuckling through its entirety.

The poem is written in three quatrains of rhyming couplets in anapestic tetrameter. This is an especially good choice for a children's poem as it embodies a musical characteristic very similar to rhythms one might expect to read in the works of Dr. Seuss. The flow is flawless and so much fun to read.

The end-line rhymes are all solid and none of them appear the least bit forced. Plus there is an exceptional internal rhyme tha I really enjoyed "That naughty Whobody...". This is truly a special treat.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS: *Notepady*
There is really nothing that needs to be addressed in this poem. I did, on my initial read. stumble on line four of the second stanza - "If he gets a poke then maybe he'll go pop.". But after I reread it (as the poet wrote it) I found that the flow of the line is very good.

*Tools* POETIC DEVICES: *Key*
Excellent use of all the sound devices (assonace, consonance and alliteration) gives this poem a very sonorous appeal. Also, the imagery of the daily experiences keep the reader intimately involved in the poem. Great job!

*Bookstack* WHAT I LIKED BEST: *Delight*
This poem is jampacked with great lines throughout, non-the-less I have finally settle on ywo that are my favoites. First, "That naughty Whobody has done it again" and "With that Whobody Whobody Whobody Who".

*Starr* Rating: *stargray**Starbr* *Starb**Starg**Staro**Starr*
Occasionally I come across a poem thay I think excels beyond a typical five stars. That is the case here - so I'm giving it six stars. Thank you for returning me to my youth with such a great read.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

An eye on your work{/left}
10
10
Review of Afternoon Delight  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi warriormom,

I just finished reading your poem, "Afternoon Delight for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION: *Thought*
This is one of those poems that makes you smile and feel good about your day - even when your day has not gone well. It tells the story of the relationship between and grandmother and her toddler grandson. The imagery is exceptional and very easy to conceptualize.

The poem draws the reader in immediately and then sustains them by presenting good examples of all those "little things", easily overlooked, that really make a difference in how we feel. This is such a great message that is light and yet so uplifting. I really enjoyed reading this.

The poem is written in four tercets of interlocking rhyme (aba, bcb, cdc, ded) and while the meter is logaoedic - the flow is really very good. The prescribed form is followed flawlessly.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS: *Notepady*
As I mentioned, the flow is very good. However, there are two lines that just feel a little bit long when I read them. The first is "The we sing along with the TV in our own special style.", and the second is "at the colorful animated characters bouncing on the screen".

*Tools* POETIC DEVICES: *Key*
Ther is very good examples of consonance and assonance as well a some short alliterations (we watch, special style. colorful characters). But the real power in this read is the heavy use of visual imagery. These examples are easily identified with by the reader and strengthen the poem significantly. I also enjoyed the personification of a "laughing heart" - that is a special treat.

*Bookstack* WHAT I LIKED BEST: *Delight*
It is really easy to find favorite lines in this poem. My favorites include "We watch his favorite shows for a little while," and "It lifts my spirits and causes my heart to laugh."

*Starr* Rating: *stargray**Starbr* *Starb**Starg**Halfstar*
I must tell you that reading this poem is a real uplifting experience and I enjoyed reading it very much.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

An eye on your work
11
11
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi SpottyLogik },

I just finished reading your poem,"The Girl Who Lost The World for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
I really like this poem very much. The concept is powerful and full of the potential for greatness as it promises that we can "save the world" - by aiding "one soul at a time". This is a message of high worth that merits sharing.

The poem is formatted as four quatrains of (a-a-b-b) rhyme While the logic of the content flows very well - with well thought out stanza breaks - the flow of the read is a little erratic, and choppy in some spots. But the poet uses some very powerful imagery and figurative language that is quite impressive.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
Stanza one sets up the dilemma very nicely - but I thought that the repetition oft the words "fix" and "help" detracted a little from its strength. I would recommend searching out some synonyms (such as repair, assist, aid, ...et al) to replace the some of these.

Stanza two is probably the weakest, primarily due to line three and line four. While the message of these lines is very important - the wording in both appears forced and lessens their potential power.

Stanza three is my absolute favorite. It contains strong imagery and potent symbolism. Just from my own perspective of the read, in line three - I would remove the comma pause after "bottles". If you still wanted a break - I would place it after "swallowed whole".

Stanza four is my second favorite stanza as it also contains strong and vivid symbolism throughout. In the final line "and her slow death" appears a little forced. This is important because you don't want to end such a powerful message in a manner of weakness.

*CoffeeB* POETIC DEVICES:
Again - I want to stress how much I loved this poem. It is actually pretty well written and contains some really great use of poetic devices. You use enjambment and imagery very well. I also enjoyed the hyperbole "plastic bottle swallowed whole" - that was great.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
As mentioned above, stanzas three and four are my favorite by far, and contain my favorite lines. One is the couplet "And plastic bottles, swallowed whole Contain the remnants of her soul". The second is the couplet "From pulling hair and pissing off, to menthol cigs and smokers cough,".

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star*
I don't normally offer so much in the way of suggestion - as a general rule - but I liked this poem so much that I decided to pay particular attention to detail. Thank you for a great experience.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig
12
12
Review of Facial Hair  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi TianaJanelle ,

I just finished reading your poem,"Facial Hair for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
Well, first I must say, you really drew me in with your title and item description. If you look at the photo of me - in my portfolio biography - it will be clear why this is the case (lol).

Now that's out of the way, I must say that this is one of the freshest and most unique topic perspectives that I've seen for quite some time. I absolutely loved the poem that you've created. It is very humorous and made smile, chuckle and laugh throughout its entirety.

Written in four stanzas of monorhyme that break with the shift of topic focus works very well to support the shift in meter without negatively impacting how the read flows. One of the biggest challenges that occurs frequently with monorhyme is - the tendency to force the rhyme, but for the most part (with the exception of a single line in stanza three) that doesn't occur in this poem. You really did a great job on this.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
As mentioned above the vast majority of end-line rhymes is handled superbly. The one line that appeared a little forced (at least in my opinion) was "it's with food that you're often struck".

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
There are many lines that I really enjoyed and identified with on a personal level, but to signgle out a couple of favorites - I would certainly have to include "Some wonder if you are a home for fleas" - this one really caused me to make audible incoherent sounds (a great thought, though I'm currently not infested).

I also liked how you wrapped up the poem by returning to the rhyming sound that you used in stanza one. I thought this added power to the closing. Also, here is where I found another favorite couplet - "To be somebody's facial hair Is to live a life full of despair."


*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**Star*
In spite of the single line I felt was a little forced, I would still believe this is exceptional work.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig
13
13
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Angels in my Ear ,

I just finished reading your poem,"The Valley at Night for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
This is an interesting free=verse poem that compares a scenic valley to a romantic relationship in absence. While it is a little unclear if this refers to unrequited love, a terminated relationship, or if the other half is just temporarily absent (such as traveling), it doesn't really effect the emotional response of the poet.

I really enjoyed the opening stanza. The poet's choice of the word "wink" is a masterful selection that leads the reader to interpret the suggestion of the flirtation intended beyond the mere scenic beauty. This is followed immediately with the "cold wind" that let's us understand that there's a fly in the ointment.

For me, the second stanza suggests that the poet harbors some resentment over the absence of the other person. This is reinforced by the selection to "look down" on him as he is "warm and cozy" in the bed he has made, while she is not quite free but wishes she was. This is implied by the sentiment that she "stands above him" but is not "free to fly."

This understanding is magnified in the third stanza where we are told that "diamonds and rubies" which once "electrically" created "warmth - with their glow" now only increase the darkness, as she finds herself to be "alone."

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
I don't really have too much to suggest. The word selection is very good and the flow is uninterrupted. One thing I would note is in the third stanza, the line 'and add black to the blackness" could probably be dropped from the poem as a rhetorical overstatement.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
By far, my favorite lines are: 'Diamons and rubies wink at me with electric eyes"

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**Star*
This is an enjoyable read, and even with the suggestion I would rate this a strong five.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig
14
14
Review of Bicycle Rodeo  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Cherokee Rose ,

I just finished reading your verse story,"Bicycle Rodeo for "Gang's Monthly Review Board

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:

This is a marvelous piece of writing that I enjoyed immensely. A narrative poem in the spirit of a Dr. Seuss book, the story - as well as the presentation - makes this an excellent candidate for a children's book.

The content, at least for me, bears numerous reminders of an era when the concept of family was strong, an the neighborhood fostered its youth and rejoiced in their growth. The moral of the potential rewards of perseverance is firm and colored in an attractive package - complete with a ribbon.

Each line of the text has the potential to be supported by a great visual illustration - which is certainly a must for a viable candidate for a children's book, as it allows for a child to participate by "reading along" with the story.

I can't say enough good things about this work.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:

As a personal preference, I would like to this formatted as "Rhyming Couplets" rather than in single lines with an "internal rhyme". I think this is a more classical fashion of presenting this kind of writing.


*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:

There are many, many lines contained in this verse that I enjoyed. Among them are:

I spun and twirled and jumped up and down.
I was bouncing around like a rodeo clown.


and,

"Okay," I told Dad. "I'm ready to go.
This time I'll ride that bucking bronco."


as well as,

"Good job," announced Leann, "that was quite a show.
We had front row seats at your rodeo."


*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**Star*

Thank you for sharing such a wonderful story with me,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig
15
15
Review of Time Amorphous  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Angels in my Ear ,

I just finished reading your poem,"Time Amorphous for "Gang's Monthly Review Board

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:

The foundation on which this poem is built is fresh and unique. Typically, the most common approach to describe the attributes of time is through personification (ie Father Time, a constant companion, etc…). The title of this poem, “Time Amorphous”, indicates that time has no form (or body – if you will) and sets the expectation of time disembodied. I found this intriguing – so the title whet my appetite.

While I generally believe that beginning every stanza with a repetition is a frivolous abuse of the value of repetition, particularly in poems longer than three or four stanzas, this poem is an exception. I think this is because each stanza is really an individual “snapshot” of time and is not interdependent on the content of surrounding stanzas. So in this particular case the repetition not only valid but necessary.

I really like the balance of the poem. There is a defined equality of positive/negative perspective of the attributes of time. That is – in three stanzas time is a supporting friend, in three stanzas time is a villainous enemy, in one stanza the viewpoint is uniquely neutral. This brings me to my biggest suggestion for improvement.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:

The order of the stanzas is improper and inefficient, particularly the placement of the neutral stanza (“Time is the currency we jealously guard,”). There are three potential “ideal” locations for this stanza, and of course which of these to use is your choice. One placement is as Stanza One – where it serves as an introduction to the conceptual balance. The second placement is as Stanza Four – where it serves as a separator between the positive and negative perspectives. The third placement is Stanza Seven – where it serves as a summary of the conceptual balance.

The other concern is the current final stanza (“Time imprisons, cages, confines me.”) I really can’t believe I’m saying this – but I think that stanza needs to begin with the repetition “Time is the…”.

NOTE: I almost never offer specific line recommendations because I think it’s presumptuous on my part and infringes on the poet’s creative freedom. Having said that, as an observation (not a suggestion) – line three of stanza one, “It wraps me in its eternal embrace,” could become poetically stronger by utilizing the internal rhyme “Eternally it embraces me,”.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:

My favorite stanza is:

Time is the currency we jealously guard,
It is bartered, loaned, and returned.
The more we save, the less we have,
What we give is not spent, but earned.


I am particularly enamored with the last two lines.

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**HalfStar*

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig

16
16
Review of Gentle Warrior  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Winnie Kay ,

I just finished reading your poem,"Gentle Warrior for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I visited your port as a result of participating in "Invalid Item. While I was there, I found this poem and enjoyed reading it. So, I decided to give you a brief review.

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
Oh my goodness... I am so glad that I decided to revisit your port this morning. Your work is such a joyful inspiration to experience. That said...

This poem is a comparison of the challenges and joys of motherhood, as set by the example of a mother eagle. While it is clear this poem was written as an admiration of a specific individual - is message is really quite universal and in such speaks well to a much broader audience.

It is structured in four quatrains of (a-b-a-b) rhyme that alternates between iambic tetrameter and trimester. The rhythm is precise and the flow is flawless, resulting in an easy, enjoyable and effortless read. The word selection is superb - like using real butter in a recipe.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
PLEASE - put this in print somewhere.

*CoffeeB* POETIC DEVICES:
I was immediately captured by the oxymoron "Gentle Warrior" use as the title. It is not only most appropriate but really set a high expectation of what should follow. I was not in the least disappointed.

Herculean consonance and assonance highlighted by alliterations galore had my mouth watering from beginning to end. It also features potent visual and aural imagery, masterful metaphors and unique examples of personification.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
This is truly a must read in its entirety. None-the-less I will highlight a couple of lines that I found particularly pleasurable. "Both scared and spent--one scarred, one bent--" is such a beautiful expression of growth. Also "Through trials and tears, her soul is torn. The price of freedom stings." is a very sonorous description of the motherly predicament.

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**Star**HalfStar*
I stand in awe, with great respect, to your talent and able use of poetic devices. Definitely five and a half stars here.

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig
17
17
Review of Ghost Train  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi Arakun the Twisted Raccoon ,

I just finished reading your poem,"Ghost Train for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I visited your port as a result of participating in "Invalid Item. While I was there, I found this poem and enjoyed reading it. So, I decided to give you a brief review.

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
WOW!! This is a really well written narrative poem that tells the story of the ghost train that transports spirits of the departed. There is really no hidden agenda in this piece - it is clearly written to entertain - and it does that superbly. I was totally absorbed into the poem.

It is constructed in five quatrains of (4-3-4-3) logaoedic meter that flourishes an (a-b-c-b) rhyme scheme. The rhythm is very upbeat and the flow is flawless.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
I wouldn't change a word of this. The poet is clearly talented and uses a broad arsenal of poetic devices very effectively.

*CoffeeB* POETIC DEVICES:
The poet use rhythm to his best advantage as it creates a realistic train shuffle to the read - I really loved that. Strong constancy of assonance and consonance, combined with multiple examples of alliteration and even onomatopoeia, creates a symphony of pleasurable sound throughout the read.

The poet also includes great visual and aural imagery, some exciting metaphors, interesting examples of personification, and a notable refrain for an emphatic opening and closing.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
I really loved the refrain "When the sun disappears, and the clouds are ablaze,
And the moon is a sliver of white,". Though the meter differed - it really put me in mind of Alfred Noyes' "The Highwayman". I also really liked the line "At a dark, empty station, the brakes squeal and shriek".

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**Star**HalfStar*
Definitely five and a half stars for this one... thank you for such an enjoyable read!!

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig
18
18
Review of Zoo Do  
Review by Liam
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Writer_Mike ,

I just finished reading your poem,"Zoo Do for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I visited your port as a result of participating in "Invalid Item. While I was there, I found this poem and enjoyed reading it. So, I decided to give you a brief review.

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
You are clearly an able and talented poet.

What a pleasure to read this poem. First of all - the title is great, I was not sure what to expect but it is actually a perfect fit for the content, and peaked my curiosity to investigate the poem.

What a great read. The content is light and is not attempting to teach me any great moral lessons. It just portrays a young boy's visit to the zoo with his mommy. It made me happy and desirous of making my own trek to visit the zoo.

The rhythm and rhyme were a perfect marriage for the content. It is written in six quatrains of dimeter with an (a-b-a-b) rhyme scheme, so it makes for a pleasingly bouncy read that spurs the feeling of the young boy's visit. And the flow is flawless. It also incorporates a nice balance of masculine and feminine rhyme that keeps it from appearing too sing-songy.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
I know that I'm supposed to be able to offer some input for you, but the best that I can do is just thank you for an enjoyable read. I think this is perfect.

*CoffeeB* POETIC DEVICES:
As mentioned above, the rhythm and rhyme are a big part of this poem. Additionally there is very good imagery, some excellent consonance, and the word selection encouraged a feeling of youthfulness to the poem.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
I don't think I've ever said it before - but one of my favorite things is the TITLE "Zoo Do". I think that's quite inspired.

Beyond that - I loved the poem in its entirety and recommend this poem to all poetry lovers.

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**Star*

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig
19
19
Review by Liam
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi sylvia ,

I just finished reading your poem,"Mom She's Breathing my air for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
I really enjoyed reading this poem. Abyone who has procreated can certainly identify with the content. It is a well thought out comparison of the reawarding yet somewhat challenging relationship between parents and their offspring.

Written as a lighthearted portrait about the family comedy of getting the children ready and putting them to bed. I chuckled audibly on several occassions as I was skillfully remonded of similar personal experiences.

This poem is formated in eight quatrains, seven of (a-b-c-b) rhyme and a closing quatrain of (a-a-a-b)mrhyme. The rhythm is predominately logaoedic timeter and the flow is very good, though it is initially a challenge on the first read = it actually becomes very smoothe with rehearsal.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
One line remained a struggle to flow. In stanza two - line one "Although it wasn't very reverent" the first foot is one syllable long and I could never quite get it to flow well. I would suggest "Though it wasn't very reverent" as a viable alternative.

*CoffeeB* POETIC DEVICES:
The imagery, both visual and auditory, is the greatest strength of this poem. Also good use of repitition in several places throughout.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
I really enjoyed the entire poem, but my favorite lines include "It was more like 'take me away'" and "Peep, peep, peep." I also liked the entire dialogued of stanza six.


*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**HalfStar*

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig
20
20
Review by Liam
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)

It is my pleasure to review
"Time Through a Heart
in affiliation with "Showering Acts of Joy Group

For use in Showering Acts of Joy Reviews


I thought I would drop by your port and see some additional samples of recently written poetry. What a pleasant surprise to come across this item. I absolutely loved it!

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
This poem is a rare treat for the reader. For me, it is a very humerous pespective of the one-sided love affair, that combine the attitudes of "too little - too late" and " if you snooze - you lose".

The content is fresh and compelling; and is presented very creatively. It is also perfectly balanced - with the first half presenting the "conflict" and the second half presenting the "resolution".

The (4-3, 4-3) meter and (a-b-c-b) rhyme scheme are the perfect choice for this kind of poem, as it is very sing-songy, and perpetuates the active participation of the reader's involvement. I could actually see this joker trying to sell his "bill of goods" - and hear the "wheels turning" as the poet contemplated this little dance routine.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
It is beyond me to offer any constructive benefit. Some poetic reviewers place a high priority on punctuation - I personally view it as an option to the poet. (just an observance)

*CoffeeB* POETIC DEVICES:
I love it when the poets word selection can create a sort of "implied imagery" without actually having to "paint the image." Let me cite an example: Line one, "Ten years later he comes to me", as I read this aloud I can actually see the poet standing there with her arms crossed - tapping her foot. It's an absolutely perfect beginning and sets the tone precisely.

While the focus of the tone shifts with the onset of the resolution in Stanza three - Line three, "As a kid I might have bought it", the continuity of this "suggested imagery" maintains from beginning to end. WHAT A TREAT!!

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
It's not very easy to pick favorite lines when you come across a poem of this caliber because in truth nearly every line has merit. But that said, I will note a very special treat of internal rhyme in Line two of stanza four, "Through eyes made wise by age"

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**Star*

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

21
21
Review of A State of Mind  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Myra Livingston ,

I just finished reading your poem,"A State of Mind for "Gang's Monthly Review Board
I found this poem listed in the current "Poetry Newsletter". CONGRATULATIONS on the listing. I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
I really enjoyed the simple honesty of emotion in this poem and the manner in which you presented it. While the item description suggests a state of mild depression, I found it more encouraging than I expected. It describes a prime factor of the human condition - that is - "we each exist always in 'the now' and are ever 'alone within ourselves'." We are constantly responsible for our actions that are answerable to our own conscience.

Though your format presents as a single stanza, I read this more as four quatrains of nearly perfect trimeter with an (a-b-c-b) rhyme scheme. I think the shifts in content support the stanza breaks as well. Of course, that is really just a personal preference.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
The only suggestion for change that I would make refers to Line five (or - Line one of the second stanza, assuming reformating) "There is no progress to be made". While the rest of the poem is written in iambic trimeter, this line streches the flow into quatrameter and creates a brief bump in the read.

*CoffeeB* POETIC DEVICES:
This poem uses some nice examples of consonace and assonace that helps to create a very sonorous flow. I also liked the blend of masculine and feminine line ends. But I think what really drives this read for me is the strong use of metaphor and simile that creates some very intersesting symbolism.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
My fovorite lines are "My inner voice grows quiet" and the coupling "In this silent darkness There is only me"

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**HalfStar*

Again, congratulations on the listing, and...
Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig
22
22
Review of Transparent Pages  
Review by Liam
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello Phourous ,

It is my pleasure to review
"Transparent Pages
in affiliation with "Showering Acts of Joy Group

For use in Showering Acts of Joy Reviews


I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
This poem really voices the anguish of a broken family and certainly brought a tear to my eye. The title is very good and supports the content. It begins very powerfully and maintains through the end.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
The one change I would recommend is the punctuation in line one and two of stanza two, "Divided now a family, in pangs of turmoil.". I would prefer that as "Divided, now a family in pangs of turmoil,"

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
My favorite two lines are the powerful beginning - "Hide me from the world, from the pain I feel,"

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**HalfStar*

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

23
23
Review by Liam
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello ,

It is my pleasure to review
{item:}
in affiliation with "Showering Acts of Joy Group

For use in Showering Acts of Joy Reviews


I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
This is a unique perspective of the annual pilgrimage to find the perfect yuletide symbol, and portrays the trek vividly, as well as the pilgim's thoughts as he struggles through the snow in search of his prize.

The imagery is excellent, which contains samples of visual, audible, olfactory and tactile, works well to set up the poet's question of Nature's intention. While it is light spirited, straddling humor, it is not frivilous.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
For me, the flow is a bit erratic. While each line or two reads pretty smoothly, the transition to subsequent lines is sometimes a little choppy. So it gives the poem a little "stop and go" kind of flow.

*CoffeeB* POETIC DEVICES:
Here the poet shows a real mastery in his usage of the poetic elements with great examples of simile, metaphor, personification, metonymy and hyperbole. Additionally, there are numerous examples of assonance, consonance and alliteration.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
I definitely enjoyed the imagery of this poem. I really felt like I was there battling the winter abuse. My favorite word play was "nature's unfeigned sincerity", a sort of double emphatic, like "the real reality".

Even with the difficut flow, this is a very enjoyable read that prompts remembrance of similar experiences.

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**HalfStar*

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

24
24
Review of Triolet to Frost  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Turtle ~ KanyáthƐko:wa:h ,

I just finished reading your poem,"Triolet to Frost as part of you package.
I selected this poem for two reasons. First, you generally write poetry in a free form structure and this one demonstrates an ability to adhere to a defined format - the Triolet. The second reason is tha Frost is one of my favorite poets and "The Road Not Taken" is a particular favorite.

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
This poem follows the rhyme scheme of the Triolet flawlessly, and all rhymes are perfect rhymes. The two lines that you selected for the refrains are the opening line and closing line of one of the most referred to poems that Frost wrote, so as a tribute to this work - they are very effective.

Additionally, you were able to touch on some of the symbolism that Frost was recognised for in lines like "I pondered the fates as best I could" and "I followed one as far as I should".

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
I don't have any suggestions for this poem.

*CoffeeB* POETIC DEVICES:
As is often the case with poems that are written as tributes to a specific work, allusion is the prevailing poetic device in use.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
I liked that you were able to replicate so much of the thematic content in so few lines of poetry.

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**Star*

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

Rockin Review Sig
25
25
Review of Strange Forces  
Review by Liam
In affiliation with The Rockin' Reviewers  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Turtle ~ KanyáthƐko:wa:h ,

I just finished reading your poem,"Strange Forces as part of your Poetry Package.

I really enjoy how a poet expresses the ordinary so extraordinarily. That's why I enjoyed reading your poem, and I have the following comments to offer:

Note: Keep in mind that any review I provide is based soley on my opinion and is not intended to take liberty with the author's work. Please use or discard any comments or suggestions as you see fit.


*Yinyang* OVERALL IMPRESSION:
For me, this is a highly philosophical piece of poetry that quietly shouts how our perceptions of our frailties transcend into the strengths that overcome adversity – how, yielding beyond worry provides an inward power that rises to meet the occasion.

*Pencil* SUGGESTIONS:
This poem is written in the first person present, and because of this there is an excessive use of “I”, “me” and “my”. It would be an interesting exercise to see this written in a third person perspective.

*CoffeeB* POETIC DEVICES:
Metaphor and simile are powerfully used in this poem. There is some very good use of tactile imagery as well as examples of alliteration and interesting personification. Also, some occurrence of assonance and consonance.

*Heart* WHAT I LIKED BEST:
I really enjoyed the symbolism of “my weakness is useless against the tide that swallows me whole as I sink into the abyss.”, and my favorite line is “My exhaustion acquits me”

*NoteG* Rating: *Star**Star**Star**Star**Star*

Thank you for sharing,
Liam

PDG Review Sig for Liam

121 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 5 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://p15.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/wohaver